‘Clayface’ – DC Studios mold a decent movie!

I’ll be honest here: – I’ve been a critic of DC Studios; due to the recent sub-standard slop they have been producing under the stewardship of James Gunn. From the passable ‘Superman’ reboot to the disastrous and unfunny ‘Supergirl’ – and then onto the ‘Lanterns’ series on HBO that was so nasty and hateful that I ended up not even finishing the season.

When news first broke that a standalone film about Clayface – a second tier Batman villain – would be the next cab off the rank in the DC Universe series of films, more than a few eyebrows were raised. It really sounded like they had lost their marbles at DC – putting this project ahead of Wonder Woman or any other choice of better-known heroes or baddies.

Then the first trailer dropped and opinions started to shift a little…

‘Clayface’ was released in cinemas on October 23rd and is directed by James Watkins, with horror maestro Mike Flanagan being involved with the screenplay. The film does not have a star-studded lineup with only Max Minghella and Eddie Marsan being actors that I recognised, with the leading role of Matt Hagan/Clayface being played by Tom Rhys Harries. Naomi Ackie and David Dencik – who like the leading man are also relatively unknown – play Dr Caitlyn Corr and crime lord Markos Szabo respectively.

With the introductions now out of the way, it is time to get into my actual review of the movie. However, as ‘Clayface’ is still fresh in cinemas, I will avoid spoilers and share my thoughts by offering up a general overview of the film.

‘Clayface’ focuses on the main character Matt Hagan (Rhys Harries) and the film wastes no time in letting the audience know who this guy is, dropping us off during the peak of his success as an up-and-coming actor on the verge of stardom. The pace is lightning fast throughout the first act, and by the half hour mark we see Hagan’s unfortunate fall from grace after being mutilated by gangster Markos Szabo (Dencik) following which the system turns on our guy and all but destroys him, leading to his apparent resurrection having undergone experimental nanite therapy with the genius doctor Caitlyn Corr (Ackie).

The violence in the earlier parts of the film is horrifying to say the least, with both the face slashing and hospital surgery scenes graphic and quite frankly disgusting. I don’t think I am giving away too many surprises there, but these moments were really hard to watch! Besides that, the film looks aesthetically solid and the Gotham backdrop is good; highlighting the class divide in the city like all good Batman-adjacent films should, and showing us just how dangerous and seedy the town is once you rub a little of the polish away. This was good work – it looked and felt like Gotham City.

As I mentioned earlier, the pacing is great for the first half of the film, but perhaps in their eagerness to progress the story, the writers and editors may have brushed past the miracle medical procedure scenes a little too hastily. I might be being a bit picky here, but there was a montage of sorts that compressed perhaps weeks of treatments into a minute long sequence, and I’m not sure if the audience would have picked up on how much time elapsed in the story. But hey, if this is the only nitpicking I am offering at this point then the movie is doing better than okay, right?

I also felt that the writing and the dialogue was pretty good throughout, but there was one line that struck me instantly as being cringe – and it happened very early in the film when Matt Hagan met Markos Szabo for the first time. Szabo’s opening line to Hagan was almost word-for-word how Mike Tyson described Brad Pitt in his stage show/documentary ‘Undisputed Truth.’ It was a funny line and it works perfectly within that scene, but it’s not so effective if you’ve heard it before.

Hagan’s descent into his monstrous alter-ego is what dominates the second half of the film, and this is all set up very well and we are given a tight story that is easy to follow. ‘Clayface’ is not Academy Award winning stuff – not that it means anything these days – but it is a solid horror/revenge film that knows exactly what it is trying to do, and just goes out and does it.

The body horror and gruesome violence continues throughout, although it is not as graphic as it was in those earlier scenes, but we are still given our fair share of blood and guts; not to mention one of the most bizarre murder-by-suffocation scenes you will ever see! Story-wise the movie rolls along at a decent tempo, and Hagan’s journey of vengeance eventually leads to a final showdown with the mobster Szabo, and perhaps it is here where the direction wavers and loses shape – but only a little.

During these final scenes I felt that the horror elements became a little comedic – much like death scenes in generic slasher films – but I didn’t have any major issues with this. There was also an amusing dance floor sequence that was very James Gunn-esque that I thought was brilliant, mainly because it came out of nowhere. Up to that point, ‘Clayface’ had used levity sparingly, preferring instead to remain embedded in its dark and depressing tones, and the last thing I expected was to suddenly burst into laughter: – and I was laughing with the film and not at the film.

Quite simply, I enjoyed this movie – even though I found that some scenes were hard to watch.

‘Clayface’ presents itself as a horror/revenge flick, and pushes the boundary with its gratuitous violence and mutilation scenes: – and if you are going to go down the body horror path then you might as well go hard! As a standalone horror movie, this passes the test with flying colours, and whilst it is set in the DC Universe it doesn’t lean into it too much – which I think works in its favour.

Overall, the movie looked good, had a great soundtrack – including a classic nineteen-eighties TV show style intro – and the performances were solid, especially Rhys Harries in the leading role.

Whilst I do not believe that this film has brought DC Studios back from the brink, I will acknowledge good work when I see it – and ‘Clayface’ is by far the best movie DC has released during James Gunn’s tenure as studio boss. I’m giving it an impressive eight out of ten!

Screenshots and posters courtesy of DC Studios and Warner Bros Pictures.

I watched ‘Superman’ – and it was okay

James Gunn’s ‘Superman’ was released in cinemas last week to mixed – yet in some ways consistent – reviews and has been vigorously broken down and analysed on numerous online channels and podcasts over the past few days.

I managed to catch a session of this movie yesterday and approached it with an open mind – not wanting to be overly-critical, but also not setting my expectations too high.

This is not a great movie; nor is it a disaster. In fact, a lot of the praise that this film has received can be justified, and likewise so can the flaws and weaknesses pointed out in some of the negative reviews. But overall – and this is my own verdict here – I would describe this reboot of Superman as being all over the place and a bit of a mess, yet it turned out to be a fun movie that I found quite likeable.

Without giving any elements of the plot away, I will tread carefully and provide an honest appraisal of what I experienced from this movie. Toward the end of this article, I will put up a spoiler warning and then offer a few more detailed remarks.

I will start positively by saying that David Corenswet was excellent as Superman. He looked and acted the part, but I think the way the film was written meant that his charm and charisma took a little while to shine through. But eventually it did.

Rachel Brosnahan as Lois Lane was also well-cast, as was Nicholas Hoult as Lex Luthor – but I don’t think the super villain’s part was penned as sharply as it could have been. The ideas were alright and some of Luthor’s schemes were decent, but the fast-paced screenplay often didn’t allow his moments of evil genius to settle before moving on to the next scenes.

In fact, this a common criticism of James Gunn, mainly around moments of gravitas or emotionally-heavy exchanges in his films, in which he overuses levity – often in the form of a weak joke or some type of slapstick – to underline the scene. To be fair, this style can often work well in a film and it’s great to make the audience laugh – but it is not as effective as often as Gunn thinks it is and many times in this movie he fails to let these character-building scenes slow down a little and run their course.

You may have read similar criticisms in other reviews, and these are legitimate gripes. But to me these issues were a minor disappointment and fit nicely into my ‘it could have been better’ overview of this film. Whilst I think that Gunn overplayed the use of jokes in this movie, it was not a deal-breaker for me – for it was clear that his vision for Superman was aimed at a younger audience.

There has also been a lot of negative talk about how bloated and overflowing this film is with other meta human characters, such as the ‘Justice Gang’ and Luthor’s goon squad featuring Ultraman and The Engineer, not to mention the mysterious ‘Hammer of Boravia’ – but I’ll have more to say about this chap later. The main criticism that has been echoed around the internet is that it is hard for Superman to be the star of his own show with all these other powered-up folks running around, which is a fair call.

This all boils down to Gunn’s decision to start the movie right in the middle of a shit storm – which it is revealed was partly Superman’s fault – and simply pile all these characters into the story at breakneck speed and allow the audience to figure it out as it plays along. Sometimes jumping into the deep end works (note: ‘Pacific Rim’) and sometimes it doesn’t, but I am of the view that James Gunn set things up satisfactorily and there was ‘just’ enough continuity and reasoning to explain each rapidly-moving jump to the next.

Would I have preferred a little more time for the characters to develop, a touch of plot clarity, and perhaps some moments to build a solid platform in which to propel the film forward? Yes, of course – but I was somehow able to overlook these basic storytelling flaws and ended up enjoying the film. I guess if I was to offer up an explanation for my leniency, then it would be that the overall charm of this movie had somehow won me over.

The visuals and aesthetics were bright and colourful, the jokes – when on point – were good, the performances all around were convincing, and the overall story was serviceable.

Therefore, I’m going to be a little generous here and give ‘Superman’ a six out of ten. I found it to be a very likeable movie; a risky take on a well-known and established superhero – one that I don’t think James Gunn was able to pull off completely.

However, I can’t go any deeper into my assessment of this film and offer a more detailed critique without mentioning spoilers, so consider this a fair warning for those who are yet to watch ‘Superman.’

**** SPOILER ALERT ****

Judging by what I wrote above the warning notice, it is safe to assume that I enjoyed the movie and was quite fair towards James Gunn’s treatment of such an iconic IP such as Superman. But it’s important to note that I described my final score as being a ‘generous’ six out of ten – when in truth if I was marking this correctly should have given it a five.

Again, I must underline that I liked this film, but it lost some serious marks over a number of issues – with the treatment of Superman’s true parents Jor-El and Lara topping the list. That entire scene regarding their damaged message, and it being interpreted in such a diabolical manner may have worked as a plot mechanism, but to not be debunked as a Luthor hoax at the end of the film and allowed to stand as fact was a serious own goal and a betrayal of Superman’s origin story.

The ‘Justice Gang’ worked okay for me, and I liked Nathan Fillion as Guy Gardner. Mister Terrific was a cool superhero and I don’t think he was bigger than Superman in this movie as other critics suggest. I couldn’t get my head around Hawk Girl, though – and if one of these extra superheroes could have had a spell on the sidelines to help ease the clutter then I would have nominated her.

The ‘Hammer of Boravia’ came and went in an instant, yet was able to beat up Superman twice in the first ten minutes of the film before never seeing him again. I was hoping for a rematch at the end of the movie, but a scene inside Luthor’s control room clearly showed Ultraman being the man underneath this mysterious villain’s mask.

Now onto the humour, where – like much of the film’s content – it felt like it was thrown against a wall in the hope that some of it might stick. That does sound a little harsh, but that was exactly how hit and miss some of the gags were in this film. For example, I laughed aloud when Luthor’s guys released the baby Kaiju out of its box and made an offbeat remark as the tiny creature scurried away – along the lines of “Don’t worry. It will get bigger.” I thought Green Lantern knocking out the Boravian tanks with a giant middle finger was also pretty good. On the flip side, Superman’s robots were unfunny and the monkeys tapping away on the keyboards were a wide miss. I’m neither here nor there with Krypto, but the appearance of a drunken Supergirl at the end of the film to collect her dog was totally dumb.

Another scene that I would describe as ‘misplaced Gunn wit’ was the bizarre sequence where Superman and Lois are having a deep discussion in her apartment whilst the ‘Justice Gang’ are battling a giant alien outside the window. Seriously, would Superman sit there talking to his girlfriend instead of helping the other heroes fight the creature? I think you know the answer.

This film easily could have been a seven or an eight out of ten, had James Gunn toned down his style of movie-making and his trademark quirks – if only as a mark of respect for such a famous character as Superman. I think he could have satisfied both the younger and older demographics had he tightened things up a little and showed some more restraint with his liberal splashing of attempted comedy in almost every scene.

So, I’ve had my say – and I must admit that this was a very difficult film to review, but I hope that I have done so fairly and in an objective manner.

Again, ‘Superman’ gets a six out of ten from me – despite its flaws.

And as an end note, if I was to compare it to the other blockbuster film released this month – ‘Jurassic World Rebirth’, then James Gunn’s ‘Superman’ wins hands down!

All photos and screenshots are courtesy of DC, Warner Bros and various online sources.